The Magic We Made: A Witchy Romance Where a Skeptic and a Psychic Must Solve a Mystery (Witches of West Harbor, 2)

Francesca Giovanni is a therapist who prides herself on logic, science, and a healthy dose of skepticism. Living in West Harbor, a town overrun by witch tourism, she manages to ignore the supernatural—until local teenage witches start vanishing. When strange, unexplainable events begin occurring at the lake house next door, Frankie finds her rational world crumbling, especially when she crosses paths with her mysterious new neighbor, Ash Merit.

Ash is a psychic who makes his living finding lost things, but he is currently struggling with his own unreliable powers and a growing attraction to the captivatingly stubborn doctor next door. Forced-proximity brings these two opposites together as they team up to investigate the disappearances. As they navigate a web of secrets, they must contend with the undeniable chemistry that ignites whenever they are near each other—a spark that defies every scientific explanation Frankie holds dear.

This charming urban fantasy blends a high-stakes mystery with a slow-burn paranormal romance. Perfect for fans of magical small-town settings, the story masterfully explores whether a skeptic can truly open her heart to the impossible. Dive into this enchanting tale where love and magic collide, proving that some mysteries are best solved with a little bit of faith.